Like It’s Going Out of Fashion

Scholars such as Roy Rosenzweig and Dan Cohen have long been pointing to the ephemeral nature of internet content and the importance of collecting history online. Rapidly changing technology, limited budgets, and  priorities make internet preservation uncertain. Future historians looking back on our times might be missing much of the robust and dynamic activity that occurs on the web. Keeping this threat in mind, what website would I wish to save for posterity?

J. Crew Looks

Women’s Clothing Looks Featured on the J. Crew Website During the Month of February 2014

Before you click away in disgust, hear me out. There is more to than overpriced t-shirts (although, I do own a fair amount of those. And overpriced dresses, blazers, jewelry, etc.). The various pages, fashion spreads, and price-points on reveal more than what is “in” this season; the website reflects and constructs expectations about gender, race, class, and consumerism.

Spring & Summer 1886 - Bloomingdale Brother's Price List

A page out of Bloomingdale’s Illustrated 1886 Catalog , featuring Ladies’ Tailor Made Suits. The Catalog was originally published as Spring & Summer 1886 – Bloomingdale Brother’s Price List

Perhaps it is easiest to make the case for the importance of J.Crew’s fashion by comparing it to a historical example. The Bloomingdale’s Illustrated 1886 Catalog is a window to the world of the Victorian era consumer. Geared primarily towards the female consumer, the catalog offers a wide variety of goods, including corsets, bustles, parasols and other items that have fallen out of fashion in the 21st century.

Yet, just as things have changed, many things have stayed the same. Both Bloomingdale’s in 1886 and J.Crew in 2014 sell maternity wear and wedding gowns, reflecting the societal norm of a woman as a wife and mother and the importance of domesticity.

The fashion spreads also share certain similarities. The illustrations in the Bloomingdale’s catalog and the models on the are often posed together; whether socializing, bathing, or attending a wedding, the women are dressed appropriately and impeccably.

Although separated by over a century, Bloomingdale’s and J.Crew are selling the same thing: a vision of the ideal woman.

Of course, that ideal has changed over the years. While the Bloomingdale’s Illustrated 1886 Catalog sold day-suits for paying calls, J.Crew has a section of the website focused on professional wear. And while the ideal woman sketched in the 1886 catalog was clearly upper-class and white, the J.Crew website has added some (but not enough!) racial diversity to its cast of models.

Obama Women at Inauguration

First Lady Michelle Obama has made numerous public appearances wearing J.Crew and she made it a family affair at the Presidential Inauguration in January, 2013.

Perhaps J.Crew’s most famous brand ambassador is First Lady Michelle Obama. Obama has worn J.Crew at numerous public functions, including appearances on talk shows, Presidential Inaugurations and even a spread in Vogue.  All of these occasions have been documented on the J.Crew site. As the brand tries to use the First Lady to attract aspirational consumers, the First Lady arguably uses the brand to sell herself as a typical American woman.

Hopefully, I have made a strong case for the historical importance of Yet, why do I think that J. Crew is even in need of preservation? J.Crew is a profitable company with its own personal archives. But should a business really be trusted to preserve its full history, the good with the bad? And while J.Crew no doubt archives its designs, fabric samples, and print catalogs, the company must struggle with digital archiving like the rest of the world. How does one archive a dynamic website?

The Internet Archive has saved the J.Crew website 1,208 times between December 19, 1996 and February 9, 2014.  Yet what it is preserving is a static image of a website, without interactives or even active hyperlinks. Interactive features on the site such as “Looks We Love” are lost.

In addition, these archives do not account for the robust social media presence that J.Crew maintains on sites such as Pinterest and Tumblr. Or the vibrant community of online users that create their own blogs such as J. Crew Aficionada (check out her long blog roll call!) Users comment on these sites, often praising J.Crew, but just as often questioning their styling, their marketing tactics (“Dude. Settle down with the whole personal stylist spiel on every single pin. We know what to do if we like what we see.”),  or if they would really wear these fashions.

Whether they accept or challenge J.Crew’s vision of the ideal, women are able to add their voices to fashion publishing in ways that were not possible in 1886.


Tagged , , , , , , , , ,

One thought on “Like It’s Going Out of Fashion

  1. drdankerr says:

    Love it! I agree, it should be saved. And of course the issues you raise about how to archive it are not so easy to address. But if they are not addressed, a lot will be lost. Who do you think should be doing this?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


A Working Group Combining Public History & Public Radio

Let them hear it

NCPH 2017 Working Group Exploring Public Radio + Public History


One grad student's thoughts on digital history, new media, and the public

Back to the Future!

Musings on history in the 21st century.

No Commercial Potential

A journal of history, art, and music.

Alex Goes Digital

Online Musings of a Public Historian

The Past and other mind puzzles...

history & new media intersections

Zach's History Blog

One public historian's musings

Becoming a Public Historian

Sydney Rhodes, Public Historian

Public History in the Digital Realm

By Lisa Fthenakis, a public history grad student


An Experiment in Digital History

Reflections on New Media

The Digitization of My Spring Semester

%d bloggers like this: